Crimson tide
Around half the world's cultures celebrate getting your first period, but in the UK it is shrouded in secrecy. Lindsay Whalen explores the effect this culture has on our choice of sanitary protection.
Many Native American tribes have celebrated the onset of menstruation,
and Navajo Kinaalda is still celebrated today.(1) Older women pass on their
knowledge of womanhood, sexuality and childrearing, and the whole community
honours the girl, who is then reincorporated into everyday life with new
status and respect.(1) Similar celebrations are found in the south of India,
Sri Lanka, and parts of Southern and West Africa.
It’s a far cry from the non-event more prevalent in the UK. Anthropological
studies have shown that in more patriarchal cultures, this rite of passage
is infused negatively, with perceptions of pain, isolation, embarrassment
and shame.(1) According to the Women’s Environmental Network (WEN)
“disposable sanitary protection is widely seen as a significant factor
in women’s liberation yet the language and imagery often used in media
and adverts to express that liberation serves to reinforce the taboos.”(2)
Adverts for sanitary protection promote menstrual secrecy, and whilst it’s
acceptable to say “period,” “blood” is still unmentionable.(1)
Blue liquid is used and packaging is so discreet it can be mistaken for
sweets. So what effect does this culture have on our choice of sanitary
protection?
The mainstream companies involved offer educational programmes and advisory
services to schools, with the odd free sample thrown in. WEN is concerned
that the marketing of products which are “wasteful and environmentally
damaging” has been allowed to substitute proper education about menstruation.(6)
WEN argues that “teenage girls are targeted by heavy marketing which
does not inform them of environmental and health consequences and which
does not even ensure a fair, informed choice of a range of products.”
Shocking side-effects
This subjective approach to informing young women about their choices has
meant that health issues like Toxic Shock Syndrome (TSS) can be brushed
under the carpet. TSS is a rare but serious bacterial infection that can
be associated with tampons and can be fatal. Health risks are compounded
because sanitary protection products are not classified as medical products,
and therefore it is not possible to find out what is in them. It is likely
that products with bleach, dyes or added scents contain chemicals and additives
that could cause irritation.
Women concerned about pesticides should use organically certified products,
and these are labelled with an (O) on the table.
Bag and bin
The average woman uses 12,000 sanitary products in her lifetime, but the
effects are less disposable than advertisers would have you believe. Products
used to be marketed as flushable, but campaigning by WEN and Surfers Against
Sewage led to labelling saying that products should not be flushed. Though
these products are small, they block sewage systems and litter our beaches,
causing health hazards for wildlife and beach lovers. WEN claim that manufacturers
are still not giving enough prominence to the bag and bin message. This
is exacerbated by manufacturers marketing pantyliners for use between your
periods, and promoting individually wrapped products. For example, Tampax
market “flushable” tampons with a plastic applicator that are
individually wrapped in more plastic! Reusable products can be more discreet
as most people wouldn’t be able to tell what a menstrual cup was for.
Added value?
Whilst VAT on sanitary protection products decreased from 17.5% to 5% in
2000-2002, this still does not reflect the fact that sanitary protection
products are a basic necessity for half of the population. Products cannot
be zero-rated due to a European agreement not to extend zero-rating to products
other than those already rated in 1975.(2) This rating hardly reflects equality
for all, but purchasing a re-usable product will mean you can opt out of
such gender discrimination.
Flagging up alternatives
A menstrual cup is a reusable cup made from latex or medical grade
silicone. It is worn internally like a tampon but collects menstrual fluid
rather than absorbing, and needs to be emptied and cleaned every few hours.
They cost under £20 and last several years.
Mooncup www.mooncup.co.uk
01273 673 845 ~ The Keeper www.keeper.com
0117 9851646 ~ Diva Cups www.lunapads.com
Washable sanitary pads are fabrics that fasten to your knickers with
poppers, and are soaked and washed after use. They come in bright colourful
designs, and many are made from organic cotton. Two to three pads cost around
£10 and they last several years.
Lotus Pads www.lotuspads.com
~ Draper’s www.drapersorganiccotton.co.uk
~ Lunapads www.lunapads.com
~ Pleasurepuss www.pleasurepuss.com
Sea sponges are filter feeding animals which live in the ocean, and
are harvested and used as washable tampons. They are not suitable for vegetarians,
and WEN does not recommend them.
Sea Pearls www.seapearls.co.uk
~ Sea Sponge from www.lunapads.com
Links
Surfers Against Sewage campaign on sewage and sickness, amongst other
issues. 0845 458 3001 or www.sas.org.uk
The Women’s Environmental Network campaigns on issues which
link women, the environment and health. 020 7481 9004 or www.wen.org.uk
WEN also has a guide to making your own sanitary towels: www.wen.org.uk/sanpro/reports/makeyourown_web.pdf.
References
1 ‘First Moon Rising: the making of a menarche ritual- a child’s
world,’ Ksenija Soster-Olimer, 12/01 2 ‘Seeing Red: Sanitary Protection
and the Environment,’ WEN, 04/04 3 www.hoovers.com 03/07 4 Green Pepper,
07/02 5 ‘Briefing Paper on Ethics in Clinical Trials,’ SOMO 12/06
6 WEN Memorandum, Select Committee on Environment, Transport and Regional
Affairs, 1999 7 Sanitary Protection Products, Mintel 02/07 8 The World Wildlife
Fund’s (WWF) 2006 report ‘Second Scoring of the Tissue Giants’
9 BUAV website www.buav.org: Heavily soiled - boycott cruelty! Viewed February
2007 10 Uncaged website - www.uncaged.co.uk – viewed February 2007