Ethical Consumer

Ethical Consumer

Telephone handsets - free ethical shopping guide

   

This is a free buyer's guide from Ethical Consumer, the UK's leading alternative consumer organisation. We research the social and environmental records of companies.

 

More detailed versions of this guide are available. See the links at the bottom of the page.

   

Best Buys as of Jan/Feb 2005

Best Buys logo


As our ratings are constantly updated, it is possible that company ratings on the ethiscore website may have changed since this report was written.


BT is the only company on the scorecard that gets our 'Best' rating for both Environmental Reporting and Supply Chain Policy and so they are a best buy for telephones.


Brand
Rating
Geemarc telephones12
Binatone telephones11.5
Doro telephones11.5
NTL telephones11.5
Cable & Wireless telephones10.5
Onetel telephones10
BT telephones8.5
Panasonic telephones6.5
Philips telephones6
Siemens telephones3

The higher the rating the more ethical the brand. This whole scorecard was last updated from our database on 14 October 2009 but some individual company ratings may have changed since then. Up to the minute information can be seen by subscribers using Ethiscore.
Learn more about our ratings.

Telephone handsets

Whilst we all know about the health problems associated with mobile phones, it is a little known fact that modern DECT (Digital Enhanced Cordless Telecommunications) phones have similar health problems. According to Powerwatch, an independent group which has been researching the links between electromagnetic fields (EMFs) and health risks for about 17 years, digital cordless phones emit microwave radiation just like mobile phones and masts, wireless broadband, bluetooth devices and some household appliances. They say that even low levels of microwave radiation have been linked to sleep disorders, headaches, memory and concentration problems, behavioural changes, even cancer and that some of these symptoms can be reversed with removal of DECT phones.

Another group, TETRAWATCH, which primarily campaigns against the new police radio system called TETRA, state that DECT base units are like mobile phone masts and they emit microwaves continuously 24 hours a day. Users of a phone close to its main base unit are exposed to two separate doses of microwave radiation. Unlike mobile phone handsets which turn down their output to the lowest adequate level once a link is established, the DECT phone does not.

However, according to the UK government body the Health Protection Agency, "A proportion of the power in the radio signals emitted from a cordless phone is absorbed in the head of the user, just as it is with a mobile phone but they have output powers too low to exceed exposure guidelines under any circumstances. On this basis, the HPA does not consider their use to be hazardous to health."

TETRAWATCH suggest that if you must use a DECT phone, keep the base unit and remote extra handsets away from where you sit or sleep, and remember that you are transmitting into neighbouring property through your walls and your neighbour maybe transmitting to you.

The alternative is to use corded phones or analogue cordless phones. Which? maintains that you get a better sound quality with a corded phone and anyway, cordless phones don't work if there is a power cut. Binatone, BT, Cable & Wireless, Doro, Geemarc and Siemens produce corded phones whilst BT, Panasonic, Cable & Wireless, Binatone, ntl and Doro make analogue cordless phones.

For more information see 'EMF and Microwave Protection for you and your family' - by Alasdair & Jean Philips from the Powerwatch website www.powerwatch.org.uk Also visit the Tetrawatch website at www.tetrawatch.net/science/dect.php and the 'Cordless phones are a pain' page on the ElectroSensitivity website at www.electrosensitivity.org.uk The Health Protection Agency is at www.hpa.org.uk

Ethiscore.org also carries a report on telephone line rental.



   

Sorry. No downloadable research report available for this product.



   

Sign up to Ethical Consumer on a 4 week trial

 

 

 

Sign up to our monthly email newsletter

 

 

 

   
   

 
solar twin august 2010
Co-operative Bank
Schumacher College
July15 new website
sust-it_july2010
stop climate chaos
walnuts2
greenfibres 2010