Story of the Day

Colgate Total toothpaste safety issues

Sep 4

Written by:
04/09/2012 15:12  RssIcon

Colgate-Palmolive began removing triclosan, a pesticide and fungicide, from its Palmolive washing-up liquid in 2011 amid growing consumer, regulatory and legislative scrutiny of the antibacterial ingredient. But Ethical Consumer's buyers' guide to toothpaste has revealed that it’s still the key active ingredient to fight gingivitis in Colgate Total toothpaste, a billion-dollar-plus global brand.

The US Food and Drug Administration approved use of triclosan as safe and effective for the prevention of gingivitis in Colgate Total in 1997, and that hasn’t changed. Then it said that toothpastes and mouthwashes that contain the chemical are better at preventing gingivitis than similar products without triclosan.The FDA is currently reviewing the safety of the chemical.

However, there’s been a notable shift away from triclosan in formulations by most manufacturers of consumer products. For example, GlaxoSmithKline adopted a cautious approach, withdrawing triclosan from its Aquafresh, Sensodyne and Corsodyl range in response to consumer concerns in 2010. Colgate-Palmolive takes the view that the benefits of adding triclosan to its Total range outweigh the risk.

The concern is based on studies about the possible health impacts of triclosan, which the FDA said in 2010 “raise valid concerns about the effect of repetitive daily human exposure to these antiseptic ingredients.” Several studies have shown that triclosan disrupts the thyroid hormone in frogs and rats, while others have shown that triclosan alters the sex hormones of laboratory animals. Others studies have shown that triclosan can cause some bacteria to become resistant to antibiotics. 1

We also found triclosan listed as an ingredient in Mentadent P and Mentadent Sensitive – two Unilever toothpaste brands.

Check out Ethical Consumer's Best Buy recommendations.

Tags:
Categories:

Strike at Nike and Adidas suppliers

23 April 2014

Workers demand benefits and backpay 

Catch 22 for land rehabilitation

22 April 2014

New mines needed to fund environmental work says company

Starbucks moves offices to UK

16 April 2014

Company will pay more UK tax as a result

General Motors - faults linked to 13 deaths

15 April 2014

Investigation launched into recall of vehicles

Rogue firms nominated for badge of shame

11 April 2014

Public to vote for winner of new Bastardtrade award

British Gas fined £5.6m for blocking firms from switching

10 April 2014

Company denied thousands the chance to switch

Toyota recall yet more cars

09 April 2014

Japanese car maker issues new safety concerns

Disinvestment campaign launched to pressure Gates Foundation

08 April 2014

The Bill Gates Foundation hold $170m worth of shares in G4S

New research critical of Apple's reporting

07 April 2014

Zero improvement in workers rights issues

Oil company pays $5.1 billion over Environment case

04 April 2014

Largest ever fine claimed by US Justice Department

Amazon criticised for dirty data services

03 April 2014

Greenpeace report highlights lack of action on green energy

 

Capita accused of disability discrimination

01 April 2014

Contractor faces staff revolt in Birmingham

Prosecution launched against two arms companies

31 March 2014

Illegal weapons were promoted at the 2013 DSEi Arm Fair

 

Wal-Mart sues Visa

28 March 2014

Retailer complains Visa fixed card transaction price

 

Energy firms to be investigated

27 March 2014

Ofgen wants to restore public trust in big six

Child labour, mobile phones and gold supply chains

25 March 2014

Mobile phone companies unable to track gold used

US government criminal charge against Toyota

24 March 2014

Company to pay $1.2 billion fine

G4S employees to be charged with manslaughter

21 March 2014

Crown Prosecution Service to take action over death of deportee

Private equity getting rich off subsidies and tax breaks

20 March 2014

Individuals’ pay at astronomical levels 

New campaign launched against Apple

19 March 2014

Campaigners target company over toxic chemicals

Primark pays more to Rana Plaza victims

18 March 2014

Pressure builds on other brands to pay up

McDonalds in court over "wage theft"

14 March 2014

Fast food giant taken to task over pay

 

Shell paid former chief executive £22m over two years

13 March 2014

Payout comes despite profit warning.

Equatorial Palm Oil plantations set ablaze

12 March 2014

Local resistance to the company has resulted in repeated arson attacks

Australian mining company fined $1,500 for polluting aquifer

10 March 2014

High levels of Uranium found in water

 

Adidas pull offensive T-shirts

07 March 2014

World Cup sponsor accused of encouraging sex trade

Greenpeace accuses Adani of ‘flouting environmental laws’

06 March 2014

Coal company avoids environmental assessment on new project

Tesco tuna brand criticised by Greenpeace

03 March 2014

Company selling net caught fish.

Mining company fined for polluting

27 February 2014
Farmland around copper mine had excessive levels of metal

G4S accused of violence at Papua New Guinea Detention Centre

26 February 2014

Campaigners call for independent investigation

PGGM divests from Israeli banks

24 February 2014

The pension fund cited the banks' unethical and illegal practices in the West Bank.

Boeing paid no taxes in the US in 2013

21 February 2014

Company won 4.4 percent of all US federal government contracts in the same year

Intern suing fashion house McQueen

20 February 2014

Accuses the company of breaking the law by not paying her.

 

Chevron fracking site explosion

19 February 2014

One worker injured, another missing.

Former Barclays workers charged over Libor

17 February 2014

Three arrested by Serious Fraud Office

Tell Walmart to stop selling firearms

14 February 2014

Retail giant sells line of rifles for young children

Toxic wastewater dumped in Great Barrier Reef park

13 February 2014

Nickel refinery continues to dump wastewater despite permits being refused

Union Carbide's direct involvement in Bhopal disaster

12 February 2014

New evidence about faulty design of the pesticide plant

Amazon guilty of infringement of Lush’s trademark

11 February 2014

Amazon not allowed to show rival products when searching for Lush

Paper company's PR stunt

10 February 2014

APRIL still clinging to rainforest destruction

Deer to be culled at Sellafield

06 February 2014

Sign the petition to save the Sellafield deer

Boycott Intercontinental hotels

03 February 2014

New 'paradise' hotel being built in oppressed Tibet

Sainsbury's and M&S rated top for sustainable seafood

31 January 2014

Seafood market leader, Tesco, declines to take part

Kellogg locks out Memphis workers

30 January 2014

Cereal maker plans to increase casual workers

Child slavery case against Nestlé, Cargill and ADM

29 January 2014

Three Malian men bring case in California

Moroccan villagers protest against silver mine

28 January 2014

Villagers occupy a Moroccan hill for two and a half years

Indian energy company plans to destroy valuable forests to mine coal

27 January 2014

Protests against Essar take place in London and Mumbai

Gap and Gazprom receive 'awards of shame'

23 January 2014

Public Eye Awards winners announced

Pulp and paper giant told to end deforestation

22 January 2014

Indonesian company, APRIL, given ultimatum by business leaders

Toxic chemicals in kids clothes

21 January 2014

Burberry, Disney and adidas targetted

John Lewis refuses to boycott SodaStream

17 January 2014

New scrutiny on companies trading with illegal Israeli settlements

G4S and Serco fail to properly house asylum seekers

15 January 2014

Government watchdog says companies fail to meet standards

Biggest oil spill fine in Russian history

14 January 2014

Russian oil giant LUKoil to pay 614 million rubles (£11.25 million)

Chemical giants challenging EU over pesticide ban

13 January 2014

From the Archive: Bayer trying to overturn the ban on bee-killing pesticides

Winfresh (UK) Ltd fined for repeated safety failings

10 January 2014

Three separate incidents in which workers were injured after becoming trapped in machinery.

Cambodian garment workers killed by police

10 January 2014

One victim worked at a factory supplying Puma

 

UK palm oil company accused of human rights abuses

09 January 2014

Arrest, assault and land-grabbing in Liberia

Save the geese

08 January 2014

North Face, Patagonia and Rab called on to end plucking of live geese

Serco prison guards accused of sexual assault

07 January 2014

Woman deported before she could be questioned

 

Giant palm oil trader commits to ending deforestation

06 January 2014

Action hailed as "incredible"

German Amazon workers strike over pay

20 December 2013

Walk-out will continue in new year

Coca-Cola criticised over sugar supplier

19 December 2013

Campaigners report land-grabbing in Brazil

UK firms halt angora sales

18 December 2013

PETA highlights cruelty concerns

Cameroon's palm oil expansion

17 December 2013

Palm oil project granted the go ahead

Shell’s false claims on Niger Delta oil spills exposed

13 December 2013

Amnesty accuses Shell of wrongly reporting the cause of oil spills

US investors press Sochi Olympic sponsors over gay rights

09 December 2013

Coca-Cola, McDonalds, Procter & Gamble and Samsung urged to speak out

Facebook in fresh tax avoidance controversy

06 December 2013

Questions over use of Cayman Island subsidiaries

Pay gap between executives and employees revealed

05 December 2013

Eight top companies paid executives 1000 times more than employees

British Gas lobby for colder homes

04 December 2013

Company asks for reduced targets to keep energy demand high

H&M pledges to pay a living wage

03 December 2013

Will all of H&M’s supplier factories pay a living wage by 2018?

Amazon taken to court by Lush

02 December 2013

Cosmetics company accuses internet giant of bully-boy tactics

Two die in World Cup Stadium accident

29 November 2013

Journalist censored on site

22 killed in Chinese state-owned oil pipeline blast

28 November 2013

Reports of oil leaking into the sea

Death threats and physical violence against Monsanto protester

27 November 2013

Award winning activist beaten on way home from work

Divestment success

26 November 2013

Pension fund offloads Veolia shares

Amazon's stressful work conditions

25 November 2013

Warehouse workers face an increased risk of mental illness

Del Monte compensates Thai workers

22 November 2013

Workers stripped of their passports, denied pay and given substandard living quarters

Barclays promoting the use of tax havens in Africa

20 November 2013

Billions of pounds drained out of developing countries by tax havens

RBS, Barclays & HSBC banking on coal

19 November 2013

UK banks are second biggest coal lenders after American banks

Shell can help free the Arctic 30

18 November 2013

Demand Shell breaks its joint venture with Gazprom

Another Nestlé union activist killed

15 November 2013

The 15th violent death of Nestlé workers in Colombia

Koh Kong's offer of compensation

12 November 2013

Thailand's sugar industry reacts to Coke's statement on land grabbing.

Coca-Cola promises zero tolerance of land grabbing

11 November 2013

Company responds to Oxfam's campaign

Dole banana plantations "anything but ethical"

08 November 2013

Dole's banana plantations found to have poor workers' rights

Five banks made £2.2 billion from food speculation

07 November 2013

Goldman Sachs, Barclays, Deutsche Bank, JP Morgan and Morgan Stanley

Ghana battle against electronic waste

05 November 2013

Environcom accused of exporting banned fridges

Harvey Nichols' fashion faux pas

04 November 2013

Department store resumes sale of fur

Continuing investments in nuclear weapons

01 November 2013

RBS one of the heaviest investors

Samsung chemicals linked to worker death

31 October 2013

Samsung not fully assessing workplace and fail to co-operate with court

Another UK energy scandal

30 October 2013

Over 30 UK energy companies avoid millions in tax while raising energy prices

Rabobank to pay $1.07 billion fine

29 October 2013

Another bank sanctioned over Libor scandal

G4S prisoner abuse

28 October 2013

UK company accused of torture in South African prison

Starbucks coffee under media fire

22 October 2013

Chinese media accuse Starbucks of high coffee prices

Exposed: Alliance Boots' aggressive tax regime

16 October 2013

Unite, War on Want and Change to Win reveal the company's tax dodging behaviour

Nike target of anti-slavery campaign

15 October 2013

Nike supplier using cotton picked by forced Uzbek labour

Wonga Swiss Wangle

14 October 2013

Company moving money through a tax haven

Foxconn admits worker rights violations

11 October 2013

World's biggest electronics manufacturer broke own code of conduct

Compensation for blacklisted builders

10 October 2013

Companies refuse to accept liability but agree to pay out

More factory deaths in Bangladesh

09 October 2013

Ten killed in latest fire

Teachers call for end to G4S contract

08 October 2013

New motion calls for council to sever ties with contractor