Ethical Consumer

Ethical Consumer

Buyer's guide to pet food

   

This is a free buyer's guide from Ethical Consumer, the UK's leading alternative consumer organisation. We research the social and environmental records of companies.

 

Download this buyer's guide as a Research Report pdf which contains a more detailed ratings table, plus all the company stories behind the ratings and details of company ownership. See bottom of page to order for £3 and view a sample research report.
 

Or subscribe to Ethiscore - our premium online shopping guide and get unlimited access to all of our buyer's guides, daily updated scores and ratings that you can change to reflect your own values.

   

Best Buys as of January/February 2005
Best Buys logo As our ratings are constantly updated, it is possible that these companies will not always come out top on the Ethiscore table.
For cats and dogs Ami, Harbingers of a New Age and Yarrah Organic are all available from online distributor VeggiePets (0239 269 9859). For dogs, WackiDog (0845 458 2291) is also available from VeggiePets. Of the more widely available brands, Burns (0800 018 18 90) and Vitalin (01765 605156) cat and dog foods come out best.


Brand
Rating
Yarrah Organic & vegetarian pet food [A,O]16.5
Vegecat Cat Food [A]16
Yarrah Organic pet food [O]15.5
Ami vegetarian pet food [A]15
Burns Organic Dog Food [O]14.5
Burns Pet Food13.5
Wackidog dog food [A]13.5
Good Boy/Girl12.5
Vitalin Pet Food12
Webbox Dog Food11.5
Butcher's Dog Food10.5
Classic cat food10.5
Happidog Dog Food [A]10.5
Hi-Life Pet Foods10.5
Wagg Pet Food10.5
Hill's Science Plan Pet Food5.5
Whiskas Organic Cat Food [O]3.5
Cesar Dog Food2.5
Chappie Dog Food2.5
Kitekat Cat Food2.5
Pedigree dog food2.5
Sheba Cat Food2.5
Whiskas Cat Food2.5
Arthurs Cat Food0.5
Felix cat food0.5
Go-Cat0.5
Purina petfoods0.5
Winalot Dog Food0.5
Eukanuba Pet Food0
Iams Pet Food0

The ratings on this scorecard were last updated from our database at www.ethiscore.org on 22 May 2008. The higher the rating, the more ethical the brand.

A nation of animal lovers?

Half of all households in the UK own some kind of pet. Lindsay Whalen looks at the environmental and animal issues in the pet food bowl

Despite lots of brands on the supermarket shelves in the UK, the market is dominated by two companies: Mars and Nestlé. Nestlé's irresponsible marketing of breast milk substitutes in the Third World is the primary reason for the longstanding international boycott of its products. The World Health Organisation notes that 1.5 million children die each year because they are not adequately breast-fed.(28) According to the Food Magazine, in February this year, Nestlé had promoted formula milk to young Hispanic mothers in America.(29) It had provided free samples, posters and leaflets claiming the benefits of its products in Spanish.(29) The International Code of Marketing of Breastmilk Substitutes states that the "manufacturers and distributors should not distribute to pregnant women or mothers of infants and young children any gifts of articles or utensils which may promote the use of breastmilk substitutes or bottle feeding". Although America was one of the few countries to have failed to enact laws to enforce the Code, Nestlé's promotion coincided with the government's first campaign in a century to encourage breastfeeding among low income mothers from ethnic minorities.(29)

Most mainstream pet foods are appealing and addictive for the pets, but an environmental and nutritional horror story. They are packaged in tins, which are inefficient to produce and transport; and contain lots of fat, sugar, salt and fillers. One alternative is to feed your pets fresh, raw food, that is not dried or chemically preserved.
The website www.animalsnaturally.com provides information on ways to feed pets a natural diet. Another sustainable option is buying dry food in bulk that is packaged in cardboard or paper.

Meaty issues
Pet food in today's supermarkets contains meat, poultry or fish or a combination of their 'by- products'.(2) It is made from meat and cereals not required by the human food industry.(3) A meat by-product could apparently be "viscera and blood-soaked sawdust from the floors of a packing house where meat is being processed."(4) Reducing the meat we consume is one of the most important steps we can take to reduce our environmental impact globally. It takes approximately 10lb of vegetable or grain protein to produce 1lb of animal protein, and the grain used to feed livestock often travels a long distance from Third World countries.(1)

Animal testing policy
Animal lovers also need to think about more than the ingredients. Animal-tested pet food is common, and involves nutrition tests on captive animals which can cause stress and discomfort. For example, according to the British Union for the Abolition of Vivisection (BUAV) website, Nestlé Purina Pet Care kept 48 labradors in a laboratory environment for 15 years. Some of the dogs were fed just half the amount of food of their litter mates, and they were subjected to weekly weigh-ins and annual x-rays, heart scans, ECGs and blood pressure tests.(15) Hill's (Colgate-Palmolive), Iams (Procter & Gamble) and Masterfoods (Mars Inc) all confirmed to Ethical Consumer that they conducted tests on animals. Focus 100, Nestlé , Pets Choice, Town & Country Pet Foods and Wagg Foods did not provide any information so were awarded our worst mark for animal testing policy. Burns, Butcher's, Happidog, Harbingers of a New Age, Suma and Yarrah Organic confirmed that they did not conduct animal testing for pet food.

The irony of using animal testing for products aimed at animal lovers has not gone unnoticed by animal welfare groups. Uncaged Campaigns and People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) are focusing on Procter & Gamble's pet food subsidiary Iams, whereas BUAV is calling for a boycott of Colgate-Palmolive, Mars, Nestlé, Iams and Eukanuba.(15)

BUAV is also running a 'no animal testing' pet food standard of approved companies. Burns Pet Nutrition, Harbingers of a New Age, and Happidog are all approved by the scheme.(15) Ami, Focus 100, WackiDog, Wagg and Vitalin were not included in BUAV's research. The only difference between Ethical Consumer's and BUAV's results concerned Butcher's Pet Care (FW Baker), which told Ethical Consumer it did not develop any "product using either captive or invasive testing techniques". It did say it conducted 'palatability' tests which involved letting the pets test the food in their homes, and asking their owners for feedback.(5) However, according to BUAV's research, as least one company in Butcher's supply chain permanently housed cats and/or dogs for the purposes of pet food testing.(15)

Veggie pets?
An acceptable solution could be to feed your pet a vegetarian diet. Dogs can readily be fed a vegetarian or vegan diet. Cats are more complicated because they need taurine - an amino acid which comes almost entirely from animal sources. A US company, Harbingers of a New Age, has apparently developed a supplement that can be added to home-cooked cat food to allow cats to live on a vegetarian diet. It also comes with recipe suggestions for home-cooked food. Italian company Ami also produces 'vegetarian cat food'. Both products can be purchased online from www.veggiepets.com, which also provides information on vegetarian pets. The Vegan Society has fact sheets on helping cats go vegan. It has been suggested that cats deprived of meat may turn to other sources, i.e. wild birds and small mammals. Cats already inflict significant damage on populations of these creatures, so it might be irresponsible to encourage this.

Genetically modified
If you don't agree with the idea of vegetarian pets, or your pet simply will not accept a vegetarian diet, buying organic will ensure animals have been farmed less intensively. It is though much more expensive. Organic pet food will also be free from genetically modified ingredients. An ECRA shop survey found that a HiLife brand of pet food was labelled as containing genetically modified soya / maize.(2) Nestlé, Pets Choice, Procter & Gamble, Town & Country Pet Foods (HiLife) and Wagg Foods did not respond to ECRA's request for policies on the use of genetically modified ingredients, so received a small mark in the genetic engineering column. All the other companies claimed not to use genetically modified ingredients.

References
1 Eco Living, Karen Christenson 2000
2 ECRA shop survey 6/10/04
3 'Natural Choice Pet Food', BBC Wildlife September 2003
4 'Wording of Pet Food Labels', FW Cusack, www.home.att.net/~wdcusick/02.html viewed on 4/11/04 5 Email from Butcher's Pet Care Ltd 14/10/04 18 Provimi Annual Report 2003
19 Telephone conversation with a Happidog representative 14/10/04
20 Labour Research: 88,9 1/9/99
21 Big Campaign Website (Boycott Israeli Goods), viewed on 8/11/04
22 The Ecologist: 33,4 1/5/03 23 Multinational Monitor 1/2/03
24 www.stopanimaltests.com viewed on 7/7/04
25 www.iamscruelty.com viewed on 4/11/04
26 Boycott News 31 1/7/02
27 www.captiveanimals.org viewed on 3/11/04
28 www.babymilkaction.org viewed on 16/11/04
29 Food Magazine 65 1/4/04



   

Downloadable pdf of this report coming soon.



   

 Ethical Consumer is a not-for-profit, workers' co-operative founded in 1989.

 

You can help us track and expose mulitnational companies. Support Ethical Consumer - subscribe, donate or buy a research report (above).

 

Subscribe to Ethical Consumer magazine - get buyer's guides six months ahead, plus in-depth analysis and critical discussion on ethical consumerism.

 

Subscribe to Ethiscore - your daily updated online shopping guide 

 

Compare All Products

 

Donate to Ethical Consumer and support independent research.

 

Thank you for your support!

 

   

2 comments so far...

Re: Buyer's guide to pet food.

Hi, I just wanted to say I have read a lot of literature about veggie diets for cats and it is all unanimous in saying that taurine is not an issue as synthetic taurine is in fact what is used in meat cat food, as natural taurine gets destroyed by the processing of what little actual meat gets into the food. This synthetic taurine is also used in veggie cat food. The only worry with veggie food, as I understand it, is acidity, or rather lack of it in vegetable sources of protein, which can lead to an increased tendency to crystals in the urine, but this is easy to avoid/monitor.

By clb on   06/09/2008 09:02

Re: Buyer's guide to pet food.

We've just been notified of a blog looking at the subject of vegan cats amongst other things. It's worth checking out and is at: http://www.heenamodi.com/2008/09/18/whats-the-link-between-nestle-pet-food-the-environment-and-breast-milk-substitutes/

By ECRA staff on   16/10/2008 21:51

Add your own comments on this report...


Your name:
Title:
Comment:
Security Code
Enter the code shown above in the box below
Add Comment    Cancel  
   

 
The Phone Co-op
Triodos Bank
Co-operative Bank
ethiscore