Ethical Consumer

Ethical Consumer

Buyer's guide to soft drinks

   

This is a free buyer's guide from Ethical Consumer, the UK's leading alternative consumer organisation. We research the social and environmental records of companies.

 

Download this buyer's guide as a Research Report pdf which contains a more detailed ratings table, plus all the company stories behind the ratings and details of company ownership. See bottom of page to order for £3 and view a sample research report.
 

Or subscribe to Ethiscore - our premium online shopping guide and get unlimited access to all of our buyer's guides, daily updated scores and ratings that you can change to reflect your own values.

   

Best Buys as of March/April 2007

Best Buys logo


As our ratings are constantly updated, it is possible that company ratings on the ethiscore website may have changed since this report was written.


Organic and natural drinks produced by Belvoir, Free Natural (01403 786 460), Santa Cruz and Whole Earth (01428 685 100) are the best buys.

Fentimans (01434 609 847) are also made from natural ingredients and are next best.

Of the more mainstream brands, Panda Pops and the Britvic brands (Ame, J2O, Purdeys, Red Devil and Tango) could be the best options.


Brand
Rating
Belvoir organic presses & cordials [O]15
Belvoir presses & cordials14
Fentiman's Curiosity Cola14
Fentimans soft drinks14
Santa Cruz soft drinks [O]14
Free Natural Organic Kicking Kola [O]13
Free Natural Organic Lively Lemonade [O]13
Ame soft drinks12.5
J2O soft drinks12.5
Purdey's soft drinks12.5
Red Devil sports drink12.5
Tango soft drinks12.5
Whole Earth Cola [O]12.5
Whole Earth soft drinks [O]12.5
Bottle Green presses & cordials12
Free Natural soft drinks12
Panda pops soft drinks12
Rubicon soft drinks12
Sunkist soft drinks12
Vimto soft drinks12
D'n'B (Dandelion & Burdock)11.5
Irn-Bru drinks11.5
KA Soft drinks11.5
Karibbean Kola11.5
Tizer soft drinks11.5
Schloer11
Red Bull soft drinks9.5
Orangina soft drinks8
7-Up5
Gatorade sports drink5
Lucozade drinks5
Pepsi5
Coca-Cola3.5
Dr Pepper3.5
Fanta fizzy drinks3.5
Lilt soft drinks3.5
Relentless soft drink3.5
Sprite soft drinks3.5
Virgin Cola3.5

The ratings on this scorecard were last updated from our database at www.ethiscore.org on 22 May 2008. The higher the rating, the more ethical the brand.

Fizzy pop

In the UK we spend over £7.9 billion a year on soft drinks, but what are the impacts of our fizzy habits? Ruth Rosselson investigates.

Health matters
Carbonated soft drinks have long been criticised for contributing to both tooth decay and obesity. A study of teenagers reported in March last year that “having just one fizzy drink a day could equate to putting on almost a stone in a year”.(1) Meanwhile, it’s not just the full sugar versions that rot our teeth. The acids all soft drinks contain can also dissolve tooth enamel.(2) Such health concerns have led to new restrictions on soft drink vending machines in schools.(3) In response to the changing market, companies are concentrating their efforts (and their considerable budgets) on producing and marketing low-calorie versions of their drinks or on promoting ‘healthier’ formulations of their brands, such as the Panda Pops brand, which contains fruit juice and has no added sugar, artificial flavours or colours.(3)
Other ingredients used in soft drinks may also have negative health impacts. Last year, research concluded that “women who regularly drink cola could be increasing their risk of osteoporosis”.(4) It has been suggested that it’s the phosphoric acid contained within that is the culprit although the mechanisms for this are as yet unproven. Aspartame – a low-calorie sweetener – has also been under the spotlight and linked to a variety of symptoms such as headaches, dizziness, loss of balance and fatigue.(5) The debate about its links to tumours continues.
In 2006, soft drinks hit the headlines as traces of benzene, a carcinogenic chemical, were found at eight times the level permitted in drinking water. The UK Food Standards Agency claimed that the products did not pose an immediate health risk. Benzene is thought to be produced when sodium benzoate (a preservative) reacts with ascorbic acid (vitamin C).(6)
Many soft drinks also contain the stimulant caffeine which, if consumed regularly, can lead to addiction. Research suggests that children consuming caffeine have higher incidences of illness, headaches, sleep problems and iron depletion.(5)
In India, it’s not just legal ingredients that are of concern. Last year, research found “dangerous” levels of pesticides, including the carcinogenic Lindane, in all of the tested samples of Pepsi and Coca-Cola. On average, the drinks contained up to 30 times the standards outlined by the Bureau of Indian Standards.(7)

Irresponsible marketing to children
These concerns have led to criticisms that the companies have marketed unhealthy products in a way that appeals to children. The Food Commission criticised brands, including Tango, for designing websites to catch the attention of young children,8 while Irn Bru was criticised by Which? for an adventure playground where children slid and climbed through giant Irn-Bru cans.(9)

Alternative brands
The last time we wrote about soft drinks, we focused on two brands set up to challenge the imperialism of Coca Cola and provide ethical alternatives. These were Qibla Cola and Mecca Cola. Unfortunately Qibla Cola, which was set up in 2003 and pledged to give 10% of its profits to charity, went into receivership in September 2005. Mecca Cola, based in the United Arab Emirates, aimed to provide a new business model based on Muslim and Arab principles and pledged 10% of its profits to local charities and 10% to Palestinian organisations. However, we have not included it on the table this time because it did not respond to our email requests for information and its website appears not to have been updated since 2004.

Waste
Three quarters of carbonated soft drinks are packaged in aluminium cans. Recycling levels are still low – 42% in 2001 – and so millions end up in landfill. Recycling aluminium is particularly important as it can be recycled indefinitely without losing its properties and it is the most cost-effective material to recycle.(14)

Links
Corporate Accountability International www.stopcorporateabuse.org
Killer Coke www.killercoke.org
War on Want’s Coca Cola campaign www.waronwant.org/cocacola


References
1 Reported on Monday, 6 March 2006, http://news.bbc.co.uk
2 www.bbc.co.uk/health/healthy_living/nutrition/drinks_soft2.shtml
3 Focus on Soft Drinks, May 2006, the Grocer
4 Reported on news.bbc.co.uk 6/10/06, Original study, American Journal of Clinical Nutrition
5 Ecologist “Behind the Label, Diet Coke” 01/06/06
6 Times Online, www.timesonline.co.uk 2/3/06
7 Press Release, India Resource Centre, 3/8/06 www.indiaresource.org/news/2006/1084.html
8 Food Magazine, July-Sept 2005
9 Which? January 2006, “Child Catchers”
12 Corporate Accountability International, Coca Cola factsheet, 2004
13 War On Want, Coca Cola, the Alternative Report, March 2006
14 Wastewatch factsheet, Metals recycling, Sept 2005
15 Observer, July 2006
17 Guardian, 18/8/06 19 CEE Bankwatch Network and Gender action, 2006
20 International Defence Directory 2004
21 Nichols 2005 annual report



   

Download the Soft Drinks report in PDF format for £3. This research report pdf contains a more detailed ratings table, plus all the company stories behind the ratings and details of company ownership.

See a sample pdf research report.

 


 

   

 Ethical Consumer is a not-for-profit, workers' co-operative founded in 1989.

 

You can help us track and expose mulitnational companies. Support Ethical Consumer - subscribe, donate or buy a research report (above).

 

Subscribe to Ethical Consumer magazine - get buyer's guides six months ahead, plus in-depth analysis and critical discussion on ethical consumerism.

 

Subscribe to Ethiscore - your daily updated online shopping guide 

 

Compare All Products

 

Donate to Ethical Consumer and support independent research.

 

Thank you for your support!

 

   

Add your own comments on this report...


Your name:
Title:
Comment:
Security Code
Enter the code shown above in the box below
Add Comment    Cancel  
   

 
ethiscore
The Phone Co-op
Co-operative Bank
Triodos Bank