Low Energy Light Bulbs


Ethical shopping guide to energy saving light bulbs, from Ethical Consumer

Ethical shopping guide to energy saving light bulbs, from Ethical Consumer


This is a product guide from Ethical Consumer, the UK's leading alternative consumer organisation. Since 1989 we've been researching and recording the social and environmental records of companies, and making the results available to you in a simple format.

The report includes:

  • Ethical and environmental ratings for 16 low energy LED, CFL and halogen light bulbs
  • Best Buy recommendations
  • price comparison
  • light bulb links to nuclear power
  • Disposal issues of bulbs
  • phosphor and China

 

Customise your scorecard ratings

How important to you?
Less
More
Click the + icon to expand categories

To save your personal score settings and use them elsewhere around the site, please  Log In.

 

Help

Score Ratings

Our ratings are live updated scores from our primary research database. They are based on primary and secondary research across 23 categories - 17 negative categories and 6 positive ones (Company Ethos and Product Sustainability). Find out more about our ethical ratings

 

Score table

The score table shows simple numerical ratings out of 20 for each product. The higher the score, the more ethical the company.

Move the sliders to customise these scores. 

Click on a product name to see the stories behind the score (subscribers only). 

 

Full Scorecard

The Full Scorecard shows the 'black marks' for each product, by each of the 17 negative categories. The bigger the mark, the worse the score. So for example a big black circle under 'Worker Rights' shows that the company making this product has been severely criticised for worker abuses.

Scores start at 14.  A small circle means that half a mark is deducted, a large circle means that a full mark is deducted.

Marks are added in the positive categories of Company Ethos and the five Product Sustainability columns (O,F,E,S,A).  A small circle  means that half a mark is added, a large circle means that a full mark is added.

The Full Scorecard is only available to subscribers. Click on the More Detail link at the top of the score table to access it.

 

Customising Rating Scores

Move the sliders to change the weighting given to each category. You can open up each of the 5 main categories by clicking on the + sign. This way you can compare products according to what's ethically important to YOU.  

 

Saving Your Customised Weightings

You must be signed-in to save your customisations. The weightings you have given to each category will be saved premanently (subscribers) or only for this visit to the site (registered users).  Once set, they will be used to calculate the scores in all the buyers' guides that you view. 

 

Stories and Data behind the scores

To see all the stories and research data behind the ratings you'll need to be a subscriber.

You must be signed-in to save your customisations. The weightings you have given to each category will be saved premanently (subscribers) or only for this visit to the site (registered users).  Once set, they will be used to calculate the scores in all the buyers' guides that you view. 

 

Stories and Data behind the scores

To see all the stories and research data behind the ratings you'll need to be a subscriber.

How the Sliders work
Move the sliders to see how different issues affect the score table
Refine each category by clicking the + icons
Save your settings (you need to be signed in first)
Key to expanded Score table

Best Buys

as of Sept/Oct 2013


As our ratings are constantly updated, it is possible that company ratings on the scorecard may have changed since this report was written.

 

LEDs
LED light bulbs have a slightly better environmental performance, but cost more and are not currently good enough for bright lights (60w equivalent and over).
Best buys for LEDs would be LEDON, a top rated but expensive brand. Also scoring well and slightly cheaper are Kosnic, Lloytron and TCP.

CFLs
Best scoring brands of CFLs are Kosnic, Lloytron, TCP, Sylvania and Megaman in descending order.

Places
to buy


Ethical Consumer makes a small amount of money from your purchase. This goes to fund our research and campaigning. We ethically screen all the sites we link to.

 

 

Lighting the way

 

A huge change occurred in the light bulb industry on the 1st September 2012. Incandescent light bulbs were banned from being sold and manufactured in Europe. The reason was that they were too inefficient, emitting far more of the energy they used in heat than they did in light.

The market has also changed since we last visited light bulbs in 2007. Consumers can now buy LED light bulbs more akin to the arbitrary shape Thomas Edison invented. All the companies in this report produce LED light bulbs and the selection keeps getting bigger. Companies are seeing the benefits too. Philips, for example, have just announced that in the first quarter of 2013 it has seen a 38 percent jump in LED sales from a year earlier, with LED sales now representing 23 percent of its total lighting sales.[1]

One issue with LED light bulbs has been the cost in comparison with buying compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs). Over the last five years the costs have reduced due to the fact there have an increase in the number of manufacturers. Our price comparison table below shows that, for a LED light bulb (comparable to a 40W incandescent bulb), the price ranges from £7-£20. A comparable CFL bulb would cost around £2-£4 these days. Matt Beswick from Lamp Shop Online talks about the savings that can made below.

While LEDs are hoped to lead the way in household energy efficiency, two other light bulbs are still available, both of which offer some energy savings compared to the old incandescent bulbs. Nearly all the companies in this report also make halogen and compact fluorescent light bulbs.

 

 

Bright light?

 

In May 2013 Which? magazine tested a range of LED light bulbs for their brightness. They found there had been much improvement in the range available with six of the nine bulbs being nominated as best buys. However it states that despite results from its tests:

“LEDs are still not very bright, as most bulbs are only available up to 40W equivalent. Brighter 60W equivalent LEDs are on sale now and it’s likely there’ll be more in the next few years. In the meantime, if you’re looking for a brighter bulb you may be better with a CFL bulb”.

 

Brightness and wattage compared:

 

Lumens Incandescent LED CFL Halogen
400-700L 40W 8W 9 / 11W 28 / 42W
700-900L 60W 12 / 14W 13 / 15 / 18W 53W
1300L 100W n/a 24 / 30W n/a

 

Which? 2013

 


 

 

Disposal of compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs)

 

The most common light bulb now is the compact fluorescent lamp (CFL) – sometimes called energy saving light bulbs. These contain mercury and therefore need to be recycled rather than thrown away in ordinary waste. Within the EU, CFLs are subject to the WEEE recycling scheme. Any company that produces or sells items which fall under the WEEE regulations has to provide a recycling service for those items. In terms of light bulbs this means that if a customer was to re-lamp an entire building, then the company which sold them the new bulbs,  would have to provide a service to remove and recycle the old light bulbs.

A phone call to both IKEA and B&Q revealed that they both offered customers a service to take back their old CFL light bulbs. However they did not offer recycling points for customers who had not purchased their light bulbs from their store. If purchasing CFL light bulbs over the internet, it may be worth enquiring how the company will ensure that they are recycled after use.

 


 

 

Energy labels

 

The European Union (EU) Energy Label rates products from A to G in terms of energy consumption, with A being the most efficient and G being the least efficient. By law the label must be shown on all light bulbs. It is worth checking the Energy Label to see how efficient a lamp is because there are still large differences, especially amongst halogen and CFL bulbs.

 


 

 

Phosphor

 

Some of the greenest technologies of this era, from electric cars to efficient light bulbs to very large wind turbines, are made possible by an unusual group of elements called rare earths. The world’s dependence on these substances is rising fast with China responsible for producing more than 99 percent.

In order to make lights have a more natural white glow, manufacturers coat the bulb with yellow phosphor. While in comparison to fluorescent lighting LED lights use very little per unit basis, the rare earth elements often come from some of the most environmentally damaging mines in the western China provinces of Guangdong and Jiangxi. A New York Times report suggested that over half the mines are illegal mines dominated by criminal gangs.2

As many LED components are made in China, many western LED materials suppliers are establishing a manufacturing base there to help mitigate against any restrictions that China may place on rare earth exports. All the companies in this report have operations based in China with most of the smaller companies having a worst rating in the Supply Chain category. This is fairly alarming considering the well known issues with workers’ rights in China.

 


 

 

Lobbying against human rights

 

Multinational companies lobbying governments have long been part of the resistance to change. Siemens, General Electric, Philips and Toshiba are all heavily involved with some of the world’s free trade lobby groups which pressurise governments to make decisions at the expense of environment, animal welfare, human rights or health protection.

In 2012 it was reported that Siemens, who sat on the board of the US Chamber of Commerce, was involved in the lobbying against Section 1502 of the Dodd-Frank Act – a provision in the USA which aimed to prevent the trade in tin, tantalum, tungsten and gold from fuelling conflict and human rights abuses in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC).3 It required companies listed in the USA to establish if the minerals in their products were sourced from the DRC or adjoining countries and, if so, to carry out supply chain due diligence to determine whether their mineral purchases are funding armed groups in eastern DRC.

In October 2012, despite the concessions made to industry around Section 1502, the Chamber of Commerce, the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) and the Business Roundtable filed a lawsuit over the final rule for Section 1502. In their petition, the industry associations requested that the rule “be modified or set aside in whole or in part.”

Industry lobbying to water down the provision contributed substantially to a sixteen month delay in issuing the final rule, and has led to disruption in the minerals trade in eastern DRC. The lawsuit risked further undermining efforts to establish conflict-free supply chains from the region.4

However, in July 2013 the US District Court for Columbia dismissed the challenge from the Chamber of Commerce and NAM upheld the new rule which requires publicly-traded manufacturers to disclose whether any tantalum, tin, gold or tungsten in their products has originated from the conflict-ridden DRC. Companies will now be required to publish a Conflict Minerals Report which must also be publicly available on its website. 

 


 

 

Ethical dilemma

 

Q. Is it better to throw out the CFLs that I am currently using in my house and replace them with LED light bulbs, or should I wait until they need replacing?

A. While LED light bulbs use less energy overall, the actual saving in energy by switching light bulbs would be minimal. A report by the US Department of Energy (DOE) in April 2013 into the total life-cycle impact of LED lamps in relation to other types of bulb found that for an LED light bulb with an average of 25,000 lifetime hours, the energy footprint in comparison with CFLs was fairly similar. The benefits only increased significantly once the average LED light bulb lifetime hours increased to 40,000 (which is not predicted until 2015).

The study proves that switching all your CFLs before they have expired would be counterproductive. The benefits gained through saving energy through the lifetime use of an LED would be lost through the environmental impact of the early disposal of the CFLs.

 


 

 

LEDs: the future of lighting
 

Matt Beswick is the managing director of Lamp Shop Online. Lighting is a passion of his so he set up Lamp Shop Online three years ago, to help people with their lighting needs.

 

In 2011 the UK introduced the EU wide ban of incandescent light bulbs; the iconic, familiar bulb was out and new style eco-friendly lights were in. At the time, the cheapest and most readily available alternative was the CFL or compact fluorescent light bulb. This led a lot of consumers to assume that the ban was, in essence, a straight switch from old style bulbs to CFLs but this wasn’t the case at all. EU legislation gave no specification about the exact nature of the alternative lighting. It simply banned the incandescent bulb based on its inefficiency and this means that all kinds of different lighting can be used to replace your old light bulbs. Leading the way in new, sustainable and efficient lighting is the LED.

Few consumers are aware that in ten years’ time it’s very possible that public spaces, social housing and offices will be lit by LEDs. CFLs are fast becoming a stop-over solution as lighting experts work to reduce costs and make LED a viable option for consumers. LEDs are being designed to be direct retrofits for incandescent bulbs and the price is constantly dropping.

LEDs are significantly more efficient and cost-effective than alternatives. Firstly, they’re built to last. A typical domestic LED bulb lasts 25,000 hours – 25 times longer than an incandescent – so the initial cost saved by using one LED bulb has to be multiplied by 25 to get a picture of the real savings. If we’re replacing a basic 50 watt incandescent bulb with a 6 watt LED bulb (which will match in terms of brightness) and paying 15 pence per kWh of electricity, we save a massive £165 over the lifetime of the lamp. That’s £165 per bulb; if you have just ten light bulbs in your house you’ll save £1,650 by making the switch.

It might sound a little too good to be true. If the saving is this significant then why aren’t more people switching to LEDs? Well, in truth, a lot of people are. Transport for London recently investigated the use of LEDs to light buses and the Energy Saving Trust has produced a comprehensive report which demonstrates that LEDs could generate on-going savings in excess of 3,372,058 kWh if installed in social housing which is the equivalent of 5,788 typical UK homes for a year. Fluorescent tubes can now be replaced by LED tubes for applications in offices and public spaces and even lighting in industry is getting overhauled.

 

Beyond the home

Factories and warehouses are now being forced to change their lighting as EU legislation has started phasing out industrial lights like sodium lamps which are also used for street lighting. As a result LED corn lamps have been manufactured (so called because they look just like a cob of corn) which reduce energy use by up to 75% so that a 400w old lamp replaced with 100w LED lamp (again, same brightness) saves £90 a year. A small warehouse with ten lamps will save £900 per year and the lamps themselves last for 50,000 hours and 16 1/2 years. The total saving on just one lamp comes to £1,485.

 

Summary of key savings of LEDs

  • Switching to a standard 6 W LED (GU10 direct replacement – a very common lamp in bathrooms and kitchens) saves £165 per bulb
  • If you switch ten light bulbs to LED you’ll save £1,650 across the bulbs’ lifespan
  • A small warehouse can save £1,485 on just one lamp by switching to LED
  • Switching to LEDs in social housing will save the equivalent of electricity use in 5,788 typical UK homes

These are big money saving figures which indicate that switching to LEDs isn’t just good for the environment it’s also economically enticing. If you’re wanting to upgrade your lights to the most eco-friendly option and save a fair bit of cash then make sure you consider the LED lamp alongside the well-known CFL.
 

 

LED price comparison:

 

LED price comparison table

 

The price of a GLS LED bayonet light bulb, closest available to 40W equivalent incandescent.
Prices were based on prices listed on the following websites: B&Q, Robert Dyas, Lampspec.com, lyco.co.uk, Amazon, Asda, Homebase, Lampshoponline.co.uk, Led-bulbs.com and  IKEA.
Prices correct as of 23rd July 2013.
Lloytron is not on the table as no nearest equivalent to 40W could be found, only 60W.
Where a range of prices appear, this shows it was possible to buy dimmable and non-dimmable bulbs.
(E) = only available in Edison (screw fitting).

 

 


 

 

Company profiles

 

On Friday 5th July 2013 Siemens sold most of Osram Licht AG, but retained a 17% stake.
Osram has been preparing for this departure for some time and in March 2013 Osram sold its CFL light bulb factory in China after it had previously announced investing more than €100 million (£86.4 million) into the construction of an LED assembly plant in the Chinese province of Jiangsu. According to Wolfgang Dehen, the CEO of Osram: “LED is the future of the lighting market”.5
Europe’s largest engineering company, Siemens, has been reorganising since 2007. Last year the new chief executive, Peter Löscher organised the company into three divisions – industry, energy and health care. He then embarked on creating another division - infrastructure and cities. “Siemens wants to set up a one-stop shop to boost its business with the world’s 600 biggest cities”, which it says account for half the world’s economic output.6 The sale of Osram and its mobile phone partnership with Nokia symbolise a move away from consumer products. It followed an announcement by the company to quit the nuclear industry it had played such an instrumental part in creating.7 It now seems that many consumers will be using Siemens products in their everyday lives after the UK government sealed a contract with the German company to build 1,140 train carriages for the cross-London Thameslink rail route.8

Kingfisher Plc is the owner of the DIY chain B&Q and a number of other DIY stores across Europe. The company received a best rating for environmental reporting. Its Net Positive report made some ambitious targets to go beyond zero impact and instead to make a positive difference in four areas – timber, energy, innovation and communities. The report included detailed discussions around each of the four areas, including a target to source timber from 100% responsible sources by 2020. However, the company did have two subsidiaries which were holding companies based in Luxembourg, which were likely to be involved in tax avoidance strategies.

In April 2013 Philips announced that it had created the most efficient LED light bulb. It said “the prototype tube lighting LED was twice as efficient”, producing 200 lumens per watt compared to currently 100 lm/w, and so would offer the same amount of light using less energy. It is hoped that by 2015 it could be introduced into offices and then eventually into homes.10

IKEA the Swedish home furnishing company, has often been thought of as a sustainable alternative and it scores best and middle ratings for Supply Chain Management and Environmental Reporting respectively. Yet the company has a murky past. In 2011 IKEA was reported to have used political prisoners in East Germany as “slave labour” to make furniture.11  IKEA was said to have developed strong links with the communist state in the 1970s, opening a number of manufacturing facilities. The company has since apologised. There have also been problems in the present day. Recently IKEA Israel was criticised for discriminating against Palestinians by refusing to deliver to cities such as Ramallah.12 However in July 2013 IKEA announced that it would consider opening a store in the city of Ramallah to serve the local Palestinian population.13

Crompton Lamps is one of the oldest lamp businesses in the world, founded in 1878 by Colonel Crompton, an entrepreneur with an interest in electricity. It is owned by GCH Capital who also own Dent Steel. In 2009 the company won a contract worth £11 million to play a key role in the construction of the Royal Navy’s latest aircraft carriers.14

Megaman (UK) Ltd. manufactures CFLs and LEDs for domestic and commercial use. The company has been campaigning for a ban on the use of liquid mercury in CFLs and replacing it with ‘solid amalgam mercury’. It claimed the effects of this type of mercury were considerably less if a light bulb was to break.

Sylvania products are sold under the Sylvania, Concord, Linolite, and Lumiance brand names. Formed in 2007 from the integration of SLI Sylvania with Havell’s Netherlands BV, the company is owned by Havells India Ltd.

Technical Consumer Products (TCP) is a supplier/manufacturer of private label and TCP branded compact fluorescent, halogen and LED lamps.

Austrian company LEDON focuses solely on LED lamps and until recently was part of the Zumtobel Group until it was sold to Thomas Loruenser. In a Which? report on LED light bulbs in May 2013, LEDON light bulbs were recommended as a Best Buy due to their durability.

Zeta LED is the leading UK developer and manufacturer of LED Lighting systems. In 2011 the British company won £450,000 in a government competition to create an ultra-efficient replacement for 60w incandescent light bulbs. The bulb is said to have 650 lumens light output. Unfortunately the company director Philip Shadbolt confirmed that the light bulb will not be available until Christmas 2013. As soon as it is we will let you know and add the company to this report online.

 

 

 

Toshiba, General Electric and nuclear power

 

Toshiba is a Japanese manufacturer of nuclear reactors, consumer electronics and home appliances. General Electric manufactures aircraft engines, locomotives, household appliances, light bulbs and plastics. It also builds and operates nuclear reactors, while its finance arm ranks as one of the biggest financial services to manufacturing companies in the world.

In March 2013 Greenpeace ran an article which argued that companies involved in the design, construction and running of nuclear reactors at Fukushima, such as Toshiba and General Electric, should be held accountable for the triple meltdown which occurred.

Under the International Nuclear Damage Liability Law, companies which build reactors are protected by law should there be a nuclear disaster.9 Essentially this means they can make a profit without worrying about the risks of a meltdown, since the public pays the damages should an accident happen. The cost of the Fukushima nuclear disaster is estimated at US $250 billion and yet these companies have not paid one cent of the cost for the reactor failures.

You can sign a petition asking these companies to take responsibility at
www.greenpeace.org/international/en/getinvolved/they-profit-you-pay

 


 

 

References

1 Philips sees booming LED lighting sales; BBC; 22nd April 2013 www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-22244564 

2 Earth-Friendly Elements, Mined Destructively; New York Times; 25th December 2009 www.nytimes.com/2009/12/26/business/global/26rare.html?_r=3&pagewanted=all& 

3 Getting to Conflict-Free: Assessing Corporate Action on Conflict Minerals; Enough; December 2010 

4 Companies must come clean on conflict minerals lawsuit; Global Witness; 10th December 2012 

5 Osram sells Chinese CFL factory; Lighting; 7th March 2013 www.lighting.co.uk/news/latest-news/osram-sells-chinese-cfl-factory/8643904.article 

6 Siemens head Loscher to create new unit and sell Osram; The National; 7th April 2011 www.thenational.ae/business/industry-insights/technology/siemens-head-loscher-to-create-new-unit-and-sell-osram 

7 Siemens to quit the nuclear power business; Nuclear Engineering Magazine; 22nd September 2011 www.neimagazine.com/news/newssiemens-to-quit-the-nuclear-power-business-721 

8 Siemens Thameslink trains contract confirmed; Guardian; 27th June 2013 www.guardian.co.uk/business/2013/jun/27/siemens-thameslink-contract-win 

9 Liability for Nuclear Damage; World Nuclear Association; July 2013 www.world-nuclear.org/info/Safety-and-Security/Safety-of-Plants/Liability-for-Nuclear-Damage/#.Ue6K_KzZeSo 

10 ‘Most energy-efficient’ LED light revealed by Philips; BBC; 11th April 2013 www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-22106718 

11  IKEA ‘used political prisoners in GDR as slave labour’; The Daily Telegraph; September 2011 

12 IKEA attempts to dodge responsibility for Israel store’s discriminatory delivery practices; Electronic Intifada; December 2012.

13 IKEA considers opening West Bank store; Guardian; July 2013 www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jul/18/ikea-considers-opening-west-bank-store 

14 Companies land £11m Navy carrier contracts; Telegraph & Argus; March 2013 

15 Life-Cycle Assessment of Energy and Environmental Impacts of LED Lighting Products; U.S Department of Energy; April 2012 http://apps1.eere.energy.gov/buildings/publications/pdfs/ssl/lca_factsheet_apr2013.pdf

 


   

This product guide is part of a Special Report on the Energy Industry. See what's in the rest of the report.

 

 


Navigate To:

 

Ethical made easy

Detailed ethical ratings for over 40,000 companies, brands and products, plus Ethical Consumer magazine.

30 day trial subscription - find out more