Buying clothes from charity shops
Charity shops are often a popular choice when looking to buy secondhand. There's often several different shops in most towns, including local charities and larger national UK charities.
Ethical Consumer staff member Shanta explains why she supports her local charity shops when buying clothes:
“I still use my local charity shops rather than secondhand platforms. You get to actually see and try on the clothes and you're supporting charities which, as I understand it, have lost a lot of donations because of the apps. Oxfam is big enough to trade online but quite a few of the charity shops near me are for local causes, such as a hospice which operates just in my borough. Their shops are an important source of revenue and they depend on donations.”
How do charity shops compare on issues like animal testing and highest paid employees?
As with high street clothing shops, not all charity shops which sell clothes are the same.
We have looked at seven high street charity shops in the UK to see how they compare on issues like pay, funding animal testing, and charitable spending. We choose the seven with the largest number of shops: Age UK, British Heart Foundation, Cancer Research UK, Mind, Oxfam, Salvation Army, and Sue Ryder.
Table of seven large high street charity shops and their expenditure, staffing and animal testing position
| Charity shop |
Number of shops |
Funds animal testing? |
Income (millions) |
Expenditure on charitable activities (millions) |
Charitable spending – % of total expenditure spent on charitable activities |
Highest paid CEO (from 2022 Annual reports where available) |
Highest paid employee/s |
Number of staff paid over £60,000 |
Charitable activities |
| Age UK |
299 |
no |
£125.9 |
£62.8 |
54% |
n/a |
£200- 250,000 |
52 |
Older people |
| British Heart Foundation |
691 |
yes |
£351.7 |
£87.7 |
29% |
n/a |
£190- 200,000 |
96 |
Cardiovascular research |
| Cancer Research UK |
589 |
yes |
£718.7 |
£425.0 |
66% |
£263,100 |
£250- 300,000 |
261 |
Cancer research |
| Mind |
156 |
no |
£73.1 |
£37.1 |
63% |
£159,000 |
£140- 150,000 |
33 |
Mental health |
| Oxfam |
564 |
no |
£373.0 |
£230.9 |
70% |
£120,564 |
£300- 350,000* |
70 |
Poverty relief |
| Salvation Army |
228 |
no |
£281.9 |
£128.8 |
57% |
n/a |
£150- 200,000 |
51 |
Vulnerable & disadvantaged people |
| Sue Ryder |
407 |
no |
£112.7 |
£54.3 |
51% |
n/a |
£140- 150,000 |
32 |
Health care |
NB Income, expenditure, pay and staff from Charity Commission figures for year ending 31 March 2022.
* Reflects packages which include redundancy payments made to international staff as a result of organisational changes and as required under national legislation in the countries where they were based.
Charities and animal testing
British Heart Foundation and Cancer Research UK are two health charities listed by Animal Aid as funding animal testing. Age UK used to fund animal research but it stopped in 2015. The other health charities in the table, Mind and Sue Ryder, do not fund animal research.
Testing on animals is both cruel and medically unsound, giving unreliable results that cannot be applied to humans because of the fundamental differences between humans and animals. 92% of drugs fail in human clinical trials despite appearing safe and effective in animal tests, often on safety grounds or because they do not work.
Charities, staff, pay and charitable expenditure
In 2023, 500 Oxfam GB employees in Oxfam’s shops and offices went on strike. It was the first time industrial action has been taken at Oxfam GB. An agreement was reached within a week. In 2018 and 2021, reports arose about sexual misconduct by Oxfam staff in Haiti and Congo. 43 members of staff were dismissed and Oxfam has now significantly improved its safeguarding strategy.
More positively, Oxfam has been a key partner with Ethical Consumer over corporate tax avoidance and workers’ rights in global supply chains.
The Salvation Army is a church charity. Around 30% of its charitable expenditure was on ‘church and evangelism programmes’ – Christian worship and the teaching and promotion of the Christian message at their churches.