Laptops

In this ethical shopping guide we investigate the environmental and ethical records of 9 laptop brands

We also look at human rights abuses in cobalt mines, the use of toxic chemicals, shine a spotlight on the Lenovo Group and give our recommended buys.

About Ethical Consumer

This is a product guide from Ethical Consumer, the UK's leading alternative consumer organisation. Since 1989 we've been researching and recording the social and environmental records of companies, and making the results available to you in a simple format.

What to buy

What to look for when buying a laptop:

  • Is the model independently certified? The TCO mark certifies brands in this sector for having higher environmental standards.

Best Buys

There are no Best Buys in this sector. We recommend that you buy a second-hand or refurbished laptop wherever possible.

Recommended buys

For new laptops, choose the greener models indicated with Product Sustainability [E or S] plus points, such as the Lenovo Thinkpad, Apple's Macbook or the Dell range.

Apple scores best for its conflict minerals and toxic chemicals policies and middle for Supply Chain Management.

But if you want to steer clear of Apple for its tax avoidance, Lenovo’s TCO certified Thinkpads are a good option (go to the TCO product database.)

VeryPC also scores well and is a small manufacturer based in Sheffield.

What not to buy

What to avoid when buying a laptop:

  • Does the brand score badly for its conflict minerals policy? Conflict minerals are associated with a number of issues including; poor workers rights, pollution and the funding of armed conflicts.

  • Does the brand score badly for its toxics policy? All electronics contain potentially dangerous toxic chemicals. We expect companies to have a policy that commits to phasing out the worst chemicals.

Companies to avoid

In a sector where ethical standards are low it is impossible to find a very ethical option but you can avoid the worst brands.

  • Toshiba

Score table

Updated live from our research database

← Swipe left / right to view table contents →
Brand Score(out of 20)

VeryPC Thinbook

Company Profile: Very Innovative Group Ltd
10.5

ASUS laptops

Company Profile: ASUSTeK Computer Inc
8.5

Apple MacBook [S]

Company Profile: Apple Inc
8

ACER laptop

Company Profile: Acer Inc.
7.5

HP laptops

Company Profile: HP Inc
7

MSI laptops

Company Profile: Micro-Star International Co., Ltd.
7

Lenovo Thinkpad TCO laptops [E]

Company Profile: Lenovo Group Limited
6.5

Dell Latitude & Chromebook TCO laptops [E]

Company Profile: Dell Inc
6

Dell Precision [S]

Company Profile: Dell Inc
5.5

Dell XPS laptops [S]

Company Profile: Dell Inc
5.5

Lenovo laptops

Company Profile: Lenovo Group Limited
5.5

Dell laptops

Company Profile: Dell Inc
5

Fujitsu laptops

Company Profile: Fujitsu Ltd
4.5

Toshiba laptops

Company Profile: Toshiba Corp
3.5

What is most important to you?

Animals
Environment
People
Politics
Product sustainability

Our Analysis

Despite tablets’ growing popularity, laptops are still the UK’s most popular type of computer, appearing in over 80% of homes.[1] HP is the most popular laptop brand followed by Lenovo then Acer.

Score table highlights

Most notably, all of the laptop companies, not just Apple, scored a worst rating for likely use of tax avoidance strategies. See our spotlight on Apple and its tax avoidance.

Laptop companies generally do better than mobile phone companies on Environmental Reporting. Only three companies get a worst rating – Apple, MSI and Acer – as they had fairly comprehensive reports but failed to present at least two future targets for reducing their environmental impact.

Paradoxically, on another environmental issue, Apple was the only laptop company to score best for its toxic chemicals policies. All its products are also free of PVC, BFRs and phthalates and so it gets a positive Product Sustainability score.

Market leader HP is the only company that scores best for managing workers’ rights issues throughout its supply chain but, despite splitting in two, it is still connected to a boycott of Israel.

Laptops and conflict minerals

Campaigners have long identified revenue from the sale of mined elements as a key driver of civil wars and conflict in Southern countries

Of the six brands that scored best, only two of them, Apple and HP, were obliged to report on their conflict minerals sourcing, the rest were reporting voluntarily.

Conflict minerals ratings.

Best rating:

  • Dell
  • Apple
  • HP
  • Acer
  • Toshiba
  • Lenovo

Worst rating:

  • MSI,
  • Fujitsu,
  • ASUSTek,
  • VeryPC

(no companies scored a middle rating)

Human rights abuses in cobalt mines

In January 2016, Amnesty International and African Resources Watch (Afrewatch) published a report detailing human rights abuses associated with artisanal cobalt mines in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). Abuses included forced relocations of villages, water pollution and child labour.

Currently, no country legally requires companies to publicly report on their cobalt supply chains and yet the Amnesty report calls into question corporate assertions that they are capable of monitoring their supply chains for human rights abuses or child labour.

Tin mining in Indonesia

Laptops contain tin which is used for the solder. And much of it comes from two Indonesian islands: Bangka and Belitung, which together are about the size of Northern Ireland and produce a third of the tin used worldwide.

Bangka and Belitung have been producing tin for centuries (“Bangka” means “tin” in the local dialect), and about 60% of the population are either tin miners or work in related industries.

However, while mining used to be controlled by the government, in 2001 it was deregulated, and since then mining operations have spread indiscriminately, with scant attention to environmental or social issues.

Tin mining is lucrative but dangerous, and unless remedial measures are taken, it’s very environmentally destructive. Agricultural land and tropical forest have been destroyed, and dredging for ore at sea has churned up sediment which has buried coral reefs and killed off fish stocks.

A lot of the mines are informal operations, child labour is rife, and safety measures such as terracing pits are often ignored. Injuries and fatal accidents are common.

Friends of the Earth’s tin ratings

Over the last few years, Friends of the Earth Netherlands has been examining all the biggest phone and PC companies’ policies regarding tin sourcing, and has rated them on the extent to which they are encouraging better standards in Indonesia. They argue that it is possible for tin to be mined much less destructively on Bangka and Belitung if standards are improved. For example, sea dredgers can deposit leftover sand on the seafloor rather than simply dumping it overboard.

Foxconn, the hidden giant in your gadgets

The products in these guides are put together by, or built with components made by, subcontractors, mainly in China.

There’s a good chance that one of these subcontractors is Foxconn, the world’s largest contract manufacturing company, based in Taiwan. It has factories in Asia, Brazil, Europe, and Mexico that, as of 2012, together manufactured approximately 40% of all consumer electronics products sold. It has nine factories in China, more than in any other country, and it is for these factories that it has attracted the most criticism.

It is famous for putting together Apple iPads and iPhones and it has been widely acclaimed as the hidden partner behind Apple’s success. Foxconn became notorious in 2010 because of a series of suicides among young workers after which it installed suicide-prevention netting at the base of buildings.

Since then, a long list of worker abuses has come to light: poor wages and working conditions including long hours, low pay, no freedom of speech or association, unpaid and excessive overtime and demanding production targets, humiliating disciplinary measures and unsafe working conditions.

Apple isn’t Foxconn’s only customer. It makes electronic components and finished products for a number of companies in these guides including Dell, HP, Microsoft and Samsung. Apple now undertakes annual audits which are verified by the Fair Labor Association, and whilst there have been some improvements, there is still a long way to go.Foxconn’s Longhua facility in Shenzen is often referred to as Foxconn City. It covers 3 square kms, has 15 factories and employs over 200,000 workers. Many of them work up to 12 hours a day for 6 days each week.
 

Workers at an electroinic factory in China
Workers at a Foxconn electronics factory in China.

Toxic Chemicals

Three chemicals are often used in electronics and have been highlighted by Greenpeace as the most hazardous – brominated flame retardants (BFRs), PVC and phthalates.

BFRs and PVC are both organohalogens. Some well-known (and very hazardous) examples of organohalogens include PCBs, DDT, and CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons) – all of which are now globally banned by the United Nation’s Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs) treaty.

BFRs are used primarily in the plastic components, like the casings of laptops and mobile phones, but also in circuit boards. Several BFRs have known toxic properties, are highly resistant to degradation in the environment and are able to bioaccumulate (build up in animals and humans). Some are now widespread environmental pollutants, with higher levels generally being found close to urban and industrialised areas (in the atmosphere and rivers).

As well as being released from factories making goods such as electronics, these compounds can be released from such products during use, leading to their presence in household dust and resulting in increased human exposure. And when these products reach the end of their useful lives, some disposal or recycling operations (e.g. incineration, smelting, or the burning practices commonly used in informal recycling in the developing world), can release dioxins.

Dioxins are a class of chemical compounds that are widely recognised as some of the most toxic chemicals ever made by humans and many are toxic even in very low concentrations. The US Environmental Protection Agency’s 1994 Dioxin Assessment concluded that there was no safe level of dioxin exposure for humans.

A couple of widely used BFRs have been restricted by the European Union’s Restriction on Hazardous Substances Directive (RoHS), but not all are restricted by law.

PVC is a chlorinated plastic that is used for insulating wires and cables. PVC is one of the most widely used plastics but its production, use and disposal create toxic pollution. Like BFRs, dioxins are released when PVC is produced or disposed of by incineration (or simply when burnt).

 Phthalates are a group of chemicals which are widely used as plasticisers (softeners) in plastics, especially PVC. These chemicals migrate out of the material over time into the surrounding environment. Many phthalates are toxic to wildlife and humans. Some widely used phthalates are known to be capable of causing changes to both male and female reproductive systems in mammals.[10] Four of the most toxic phthalates are restricted by the RoHS Directive.

What about the companies?

Apple leads the way in the electronics industry having phased out PVC and BFR in its products, including its cables, way back in 2008. Apple products are also free from phthalates. So there is no excuse for other companies not to follow suit.

To get our best rating for a toxic chemicals policy, like Apple, a company must have phased out the use of all three chemicals or have set a date by which it will have done so.

Unfortunately, most companies get our worst rating for having no commitment to totally phasing out all three of these chemicals. Companies who get a worst rating for toxic chemicals could also not get a best rating for Environmental Reporting. This affected two companies who would otherwise have got a best rating in the Environmental Reporting category – ASUS and Fujitsu.

Some companies get our middle rating for toxic chemicals because they have some toxic chemical-free products and have committed to phasing the chemicals out, but have not gone that step further to get our best rating by setting a target date for their phase-out.

Best toxics rating – Apple

Middle toxics rating – Acer, Dell, HP, Lenovo, Toshiba, VeryPC

Worst toxics rating – ASUS, Fujitsu,  MSI

Greener models

Toxic chemical-free models

We checked all the brands and models that are covered in these guides to see whether any of them were PVC-, BFR- and phthalate-free. Those models that were ‘toxic chemical-free’, represented by a [S] next to the brand name on the score tables, received a positive mark in the Product Sustainability column. Models that were PVC- and BFR- free received a half point, whilst models that were free of all three chemicals received a whole point.
 
PVC, BFR and phthalate free - All Apple MacBooks

PVC and BFR free - Dell XPS, Precision and Latitude (excluding peripheral accessories)

TCO Certification

‘TCO Certified’ is the international sustainability certification for IT products that was set up in 1992 and is run by a Swedish non-profit organisation. It is a voluntary scheme which is third-party verified. TCO certification combines requirements for social responsibility at the site of manufacture, user safety and ergonomic design, and minimal environmental impacts for the product during its whole life cycle. The criteria include Energy Star (a voluntary US government energy efficiency program), compliance for energy consumption, zero or low use of certain hazardous substances, and involvement in conflict-free minerals programs.

Only two companies Dell and Lenovo  – had any TCO certified models:

Laptops – 9 Dell Latitudes, Dell Chromebooks and 9 Lenovo Thinkpad models.

On the score table we have given TCO Certified models a Product Sustainability plus point, highlighted by a [T] next to the brand name. To find the Dell Latitude and Lenovo ThinkPad laptop model numbers, go to the TCO product database.

Energy use

Laptops consume 85% less energy than a desktop computer. Tablets consume even less energy than a laptop because they have lower-powered processors, and hybrids are somewhere in between. E-readers and smartphones consume the least amount of energy in use.

But energy is also consumed by data centres whenever we access the internet. According to a 2015 Greenpeace report, “The rapid growth of the cloud and our use of the internet have produced a collective electricity demand that would currently rank in the top six if compared alongside countries; that electricity demand is expected to increase by 60% or more by 2020 as the online population and our reliance on the internet steadily increase.”

As internet use and cloud storage increases, there is more and more demand for data centre capacity, ultimately increasing the total amount of electricity consumed and the associated pollution from electricity generation.

Greenpeace is campaigning for leading internet companies to power their data centres with renewable energy rather than dirty energy like coal.

Laptop, tablet or Hybrid?

A laptop’s larger screen, full-sized keyboard and large hard drive make many tasks easier, and they’re great for browsing the web.

Laptops are better if you:

  • want to work on them, write long emails, organise files, and edit text documents, photos and spreadsheets
  • want to store files and photos on the device and access them without an internet connection
  • play DVDs.

A tablet is a gadget that’s slim and lightweight, and easy to use. Tablets are better if you:

  • want to play – browse the web, read ebooks, watch videos, shop online, and stay in touch with family and friends.
  • want it to be more portable
  • only need to type short emails, do internet searches and simple forms for online shopping
  • don’t need it as your main storage device and are happy to keep some files online.

A laptop-tablet hybrid can offer the best of both worlds. With touch-screens that rotate and flip and keyboards that detach or can be hidden away, they can be as powerful or portable as you want.

Operating systems

When choosing a brand of tablet or laptop you may also want to bear in mind the operating system that runs it. The operating systems are owned by three companies which all feature in this report – Apple, Google and Microsoft.

    Apple iOS – all Apple products
    Google Android – most non-Apple tablets.
    Google Chrome – Chromebook laptops.
    Microsoft Windows – most laptops and hybrids

You can also use an open source operating system such as Linux. Beginner’s guide to open source.

What is a Chromebook?

A Chromebook is a low-cost laptop, but instead of running the Windows 10 or Mac OS X operating system, a Chromebook runs Google’s Chrome operating system. They start up quickly and have a long battery life, but they are designed to be used primarily while connected to the Internet, with most programs and documents living in the cloud.

Acer, ASUS, Dell, HP, Lenovo and Toshiba all make Chromebooks.

How to prolong your battery life

  • turn down brightness of screen
  • use power saving modes and set sleep mode and screen timeouts to minimum
  • close apps
  • close Wifi, GPS and Bluetooth until you need them.

Company Profile

The Chinese-based Lenovo Group has risen to the top of the worldwide PC market, ahead of HP and Dell. Lenovo was formed from the acquisition of IBM’s Personal Computing division in 2005. In 2014 it bought Motorola’s mobile phone business.

Lenovo is part-owned by the Chinese private investment firm Legend Holdings, which also has a stake in Pizza Express. As a result, Lenovo picks up marks for Pizza Express’ unsustainable sourcing of palm oil.
 
Want to know more?

If you want to find out detailed information about a company and more about its ethical rating, then click on a brand name in the Score table above.

This information is reserved for subscribers only. Don't miss out, become a subscriber today.

Start your 30 day trial today!

Ethics made easy - comprehensive, simple to use, transparent and reliable ethical rankings. Subscribe today for a wealth of data at your fingertips.

We will take payment when you order, but you can cancel by phone or email within 30 days for a full no-questions-asked refund!

Start your 30 day trial today!

 References:

  1. MINTEL – Desktop and Laptop Computers, August 2014
  2. MINTEL – Tablet computers November 2013